One of the things I like about iTunes is that it's easy to sort songs (rather than albums) by popularity. This is especially helpful for bands that released a lot of songs as singles between albums or who released a lot of EPs. The Jam is one of those bands with a complicated discography and it's further complicated by the fact that I first really got to know The Jam through their double-LP best-of-collection Snap, which was later truncated to fit on CD as Compact Snap.
Here are the top songs by The Jam based on current iTunes rankings along with the rank of their singles on rate your music (rym), rank of songs on Vinyl Surrender (vs), and my own personal nothing but good things (nbgt) ranking.
#1 Town Called Malice (rym #2, vs #1, nbgt #6)
#2 That's Entertainment (rym #1, vs #2, nbgt #1)
#3 In The City (rym #6, vs #11, nbgt #2)
#4 Beat Surrender (rym #18, vs #10, nbgt #3)
#5 Start! (rym #8, vs #9, nbgt #10)
#6 The Modern World (rym #14, vs #18, nbgt #4)
#7 The Bitterest Pill (rym NA, vs NA, nbgt NA)
#8 Down in the Tube Station at Midnight (rym #3, vs #5, nbgt #5)
#9 English Rose (rym NA, vs NA, nbgt NA)
#10 Eton Rifles (rym #7, vs #7, nbgt #15)
#11 Ghosts (rym NA, vs #4, nbgt NA)
#12 Thick as Thieves(rym NA, vs NA, nbgt NA)
#13 Going Underground (rym #4, vs #3, nbgt #9)
#14 The Butterfly Collector (rym, b-side of #5, vs NA, nbgt #19)
#15 Pretty Green (rym NA, vs #13, nbgt NA)
#16 David Watts (rym #11, vs NA, nbgt #16)
#17 Absolute Beginners (rym #13, vs #20, nbgt #14)
#18 Mr. Clean (rym #15, vs NA, nbgt #18)
#19 Liza Radley (rym NA, vs NA, nbgt NA)
#20 Away from the Numbers (rym NA, vs NA, nbgt NA)
Notable songs outside of the iTunes top 20
Strange Town (rym #5, vs NA, nbgt #7)
To Be Someone (rym NA, vs #8, nbgt NA)
Smithers-Jones (rym b-side of #9, vs NA, nbgt #8)
Funeral Pyre (rym #10, vs NA, nbgt NA)
News of the World (rym NA, vs NA, nbgt #11)
All Around the World (rym #17, vs NA, nbgt #12)
Dreams of Children (rym b-side of #4, vs NA, nbgt #13)
I Need You (rym #12, vs NA, nbgt NA)
Man in the Corner Shop (rym NA, vs #14, nbgt NA)
Saturday's Kids (rym #16, vs NA, nbgt NA)
A Bomb in Wardour St (rym b-side of #11, vs #6, nbgt #17)
Just Who Is the 5 O'clock Hero (rym #19, vs NA, nbgt NA)
Tales of the Riverbank [fanclub version] (rym #20, vs NA, nbgt #20)
On the whole the iTunes rankings are pretty well in line with all the other rankings. Bitterest Pill ranks high on iTunes without making it on any of the other top 20s, and both Down in the Tube Station and Midnight and Going Underground are less popular on iTunes versus every other list, but not by all that much really.
English Rose makes the iTunes top 10 and none of the other lists. That's one of the songs that was on Snap and not on Compact Snap. I wonder how many people are filling in that digital gap on iTunes. Strange Town makes the top 10 of every other list, but misses the iTunes top 20 entirely. Strange.
All-Time Top 10 Most Popular Posts
- Top 500 Songs of the 1970s
- Top 400 Songs of the 1950s (a countdown)
- The 250 Most Archetypical New Wave Songs
- Top 500 Songs of the 1960s
- Top 500 Songs of the 1980s
- One Hit Classic Rock Wonders
- The Best Discography Sites - Part 2 of 5
- Best Tracks of 2011 (with the benefit of a year's reflection)
- Epic Songs Revisited
- The Early Year-end Music Lists of 2013
Hi, nbgt, I wanted to see *your* order so I sorted your list, see below. I like your #1, and you seem to like the earlier stuff. My favorite (Jam) album is Setting Sons, so the tracks from that would be high on my list.
ReplyDeleteyours in Jam-fandom, williamwmeyer (from rym)
ngbt #01 #2 That's Entertainment (rym #1, vs #2,
ngbt #02 #3 In The City (rym #6, vs #11,
ngbt #03 #4 Beat Surrender (rym #18, vs #10,
ngbt #04 #6 The Modern World (rym #14, vs #18,
ngbt #05 #8 Down in the Tube Station at Midnight (rym #3, vs #5,
ngbt #06 #1 Town Called Malice (rym #2, vs #1,
ngbt #07 Strange Town (rym #5, vs NA,
ngbt #08 Smithers-Jones (rym b-side of #9, vs NA,
ngbt #09 #13 Going Underground (rym #4, vs #3,
ngbt #10 #5 Start! (rym #8, vs #9,
ngbt #11 News of the World (rym NA, vs NA,
ngbt #12 All Around the World (rym #17, vs NA,
ngbt #13 Dreams of Children (rym b-side of #4, vs NA,
ngbt #14 #17 Absolute Beginners (rym #13, vs #20,
ngbt #15 #10 Eton Rifles (rym #7, vs #7,
ngbt #16 #16 David Watts (rym #11, vs NA,
ngbt #17 A Bomb in Wardour St (rym b-side of #11, vs #6,
ngbt #18 #18 Mr. Clean (rym #15, vs NA,
ngbt #19 #14 The Butterfly Collector (rym, b-side of #5, vs NA,
ngbt #20 Tales of the Riverbank [fanclub version] (rym #20, vs NA,
ngbt NA #11 Ghosts (rym NA, vs #4,
ngbt NA #12 Thick as Thieves(rym NA, vs NA,
ngbt NA #15 Pretty Green (rym NA, vs #13,
ngbt NA #19 Liza Radley (rym NA, vs NA,
ngbt NA #20 Away from the Numbers (rym NA, vs NA,
ngbt NA #7 The Bitterest Pill (rym NA, vs NA,
ngbt NA #9 English Rose (rym NA, vs NA,
ngbt NA Funeral Pyre (rym #10, vs NA,
ngbt NA I Need You (rym #12, vs NA,
ngbt NA Just Who Is the 5 O'clock Hero (rym #19, vs NA,
ngbt NA Man in the Corner Shop (rym NA, vs #14,
ngbt NA Saturday's Kids (rym #16, vs NA,
ngbt NA To Be Someone (rym NA, vs #8,